O'Toole's Way Menu
O'Toole's Way, located in New York City, is a must-visit spot for those looking for a fantastic dining experience. Specializing in New American cuisine and offering a wide selection of beers and cocktails, this cocktail bar is perfect for groups and offers outdoor seating. Customers rave about the top-notch service and mouth-watering dishes, such as the delicious Pork Chop, Fish & Chips, Cookie Skillet dessert, and the famous Dangerous Dave's Dublin Dip. The fresh ingredients and friendly bartenders add to the overall great atmosphere of the place. Don't miss out on the fantastic food and ambiance at O'Toole's Way - a true gem in the bustling city.
Small Plates
Devils On Horseback Plate
Goat cheese, port reduction.
House Chips Plate
Irish cheddar, onion dip.
Irish Cheese Board Plate
Irish cheddar, cashel blue, gubbeen crackers, quince, fig, pear.
House Made Soda Bread
whipped marmite butter
Red Pepper Hummus
market vegetable crudités
Espresso Rubbed Chicken Wings
choice of buffalo or bourbon bbq, blue cheese dressing, crudités
Irish Nachos
house chips, cheese sauce, bacon, pickled fresnos chili pepper, sour cream, scallions
Sausage Roll
hand rolled spiced Irish Sausage, puff pastry, hp sauce
Traditional Cobb Salad
Blue cheese, egg, avocado, bacon market greens, red wine vinaigrette.
Kale Caesar Salad
Parmesan, croutons, charred lime, Caesar dressing.
Pub Salad
Seasonal vegetable, house dressing.
The High Line Salad
Quinoa, hummus, broccoli, dried cranberry, carrot, toasted almonds, maple dressing.
Potato Leek Soup
Soups & Salads
Bar Pies
Prosciutto
Goat cheese, arugula, hot honey.
Margherita
Tomato, mozzarella, basil.
Garden Squash
mozzarella, pumpkin seed pesto, parmesan
O'Toole's Burger
American, caramalized onions, burger sauce, b+b pickles, brioche bun.
Chicken Sandwich
Pickled fresno, hot honey slaw, remoulade, brioche bun.
Bagel & Lox
everything or plain bagel, cream cheese, capers, cucumber, pickled red onion
"Dangerous Dave's" Dublin Dip
shaved prime rib, irish cheddar, caramelized onions, horseradish, served on ciabatta, "with its own gravy"
Ham & Cheese Toasties
House cured & carved ham, coleslaw, irish cheddar, toasted brioche.
Sandwiches & Burgers
Brunch Mains
Eggs Any Style
eggs any style, home fries, toasted sourdough, bacon
Eggs Blackstone
poached eggs, hollandaise, bacon, grilled tomato, toasted sourdough
Chicken + Waffles
berry butter, hot honey
The "Sand Hog Breakfast"
espresso rubbed grilled skirt steak, breakfast potatoes, grilled tomato, fried eggs, spicy steak sauce
Avocado Toast
smashed avocado, grilled sourdough, charred lime
Brioche French Toast
Roasted Mushroom Toast
Marsala, whipped goat cheese, sourdough
Fillet Of Salmon Plate
Salsa rosa, arugula salad, charred lime.
Proper Fish And Chips Plate
Guinness battered cod, crushed peas, tartar, salt and vinager.
Mussels And Fries Plate
Irish cider, garlic, cream, lemon, parsley.
Butternut Squash Ravioli
burnt butter, crispy sage, toasted hazelnuts
Berkshire Pork Chop Plate
charred carrots, carrot top chimichurri, apple cider, bourbon reduction
Steak Frites
oz Espresso Rub Prime NY Strip, truffle butter, watercress, roasted garlic, fries
Brick Chicken
buttermilk caesar slaw, charred lemon, fries
Charred Cauliflower Steak
cauliflower and quinoa cous cous, spinach & cherry tomato, nigella seeds
Grilled Ahi Tuna
Roasted tomato, Black olive dressing
Large Plates
Sides
Side Fries
Fries With Parmesan & Truffle Oil
Grilled Asparagus
Colcannon
Irish mashed potatoes.
Dirty Fries Plate
Short rib gravy, Irish cheddar, scallions.
Zucchini
lemon, parmeson
Breakfast Potatoes
peppers, salt, pepper
Side Bacon
Breakfast Sausage
chicken, apple, maple
Black Pudding
Blood Sausage from Ireland
Baked Beans
Toasted Bagel
Cream cheese or butter
Dangerous Dave's Key Lime Pie
toasted coconut, chantilly cream
Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie Skillet
Vanilla ice cream, Jamason whiskey salted caramel
